So, I am a war veteran. I am not a guy that went and spent 2 years unsupported behind enemy lines and disrupted and harrassed the enemy on their home ground. In that regard, I am like 99.99995% of all war veterans. I have not shot anyone, ever. I have not pushed the bomb release button on anyone, ever.
That is my disclosure about my personal involvement. Lost friends, saw some things that have been with me ever since, and will stay until I die. Experienced stuff that just belongs there and then, and I work hard to leave it that way. But there are war memorials I go to, because it is not just another name etched in granite. Those letters are a face, a friend, a loss.
So, I am careful to tell folks I don't understand a Chris Kyle. Who does anyway? I have my own conflicts with my own guilt. I was really, really good at my job. That meant we sent planes to the target, full of explosives, every time we intended to do so. It is a hard thing for me, as I feel complicit in the deaths of hundreds of thousands of people. There is not one single human being I feel competent to pass the sentence of death upon, on my own. I am not God, I don't and won't know enough, ever.
I am not ashamed of what I did in the military. If you allow rats and vermin to live with you, without doing your utmost to get rid of them yourself, you cannot get too upset at the effects of the pesticide that gets used to eradicate them. And, it is not about Islam, or Iraqi or Afghani. It is about vermin that live in human form. In that way, they are indistinguishable from our homegrown skin heads, ecoterrorists, gangs and drug rings. What happened to that Jordanian pilot is not new or unusual. These are not people that operate in the bands of normalcy as found in America. Just like Timothy McVeigh, the Bloods and Crips, and Eric Rudolph, that is what ISIS is.
So, I am proud to be part of liberating and protecting Kuwait, going after Al Qaeda and the Taliban. I am certain that it was the right thing to do. We, however, had no business in Iraq the second time or Afghanistan. I have said it many times, until Saddam Hussein developed a camel that could cross an ocean submerged, he was a threat like the boogey man is a threat. We developed the breeding ground for ISIS and the mess we face today, with our idiotic actions in Iraq. And God only knows what will come out of our actions in Afghanistan. That does not mean I was not a willing participant, nor do I demean the valor and sacrifice and devotion of all the service members that were there. It was dumb, but it was our duty and our orders, and it was done masterfully, bravely and with honor. I did not get a vote or opinion on whether we should do it, and I did everything I could in my power to make sure we did it even though I thought it stupid.
The funny thing about honor, it can be maintained, even while being involved in something ill advised or downright stupid. The charge of the Light Brigade, supremely famous, stupid and ill advised, but remembered because of the honor of the participants. Pickett's Charge, extremely ill advised, extremely wasteful of lives, and for the wrong side of the conflict, but remembered in our pantheon because of the honor of the individuals.
That is what we do not understand in America, really, in the "civilized" world. There is no absolute scale of honor. The actions of ISIS are predicated on the culture from which it rose. Islam is not the point, and never has been. It is as ridiculous as saying World War II was about Christianity, because predominately Christian nations were involved and won. We are facing tribal cultures and practices that are shocking and foreign because it does not match up with our own memories. What happened to that Jordanian pilot happened alot on the Great Plains, in the skirmishing between Indian tribes and the fight with American expansion. Perhaps not with a cage and gasoline, but the tribe gathered and watching as an enemy is tortured with fire.
All that being said, I tell you that there is a large segment of Hajii culture that sees honor in ISIS. Perverse as that seems to us, it is still true. These are largely underemployed, economically disadvantaged young men of tribes or families without connections or status that feel left behind by the increasingly Westernized culture around them. It becomes easy to bring them into a new tribe that preserves honor, offers hope and opportunity and stands for something they can believe in.
Sounds exactly like how gangs in our increasingly poor and disadvantaged areas continue to recruit young men into their ranks. It is not so different from phenomenon we see here in America, and comes from the same roots and issues. And, if you analyze what gained Ho Chi Min, Mao, Hitler, Mohammed, even St. Paul, adherants and followers, you see that it is the same formula at its base.
This means that American boots on the ground in Iraq and Syria will not stop, solve or eliminate ISIS. We will kill a boatload of them and every living thing in close proximity to them. We will destroy their identified weapons and hiding holes. But, it will not change what drives the hydra. It is just cutting off a couple more heads.
Egyptian, Lybian and Syrian unrest comes from within. Al Qaeda developed as a result of the disenfranchisement of many tribes in a particular region, due to the unfathomable wealth of oil and the great divide between the rich and poor in that region. They then found a disenfranchised son of a prominent family to lend them legitimacy and connections to groups with money to spare.
It is a sobering thing, because it is repeating in Syria right now. But, instead of finding another disenfranchised son named Bin Laden, they have tapped into deeper pockets. They have gotten Westerners to come join the cause. And while the Bin Ladens are very, very wealthy, they have pennies compared to the financial capability of the Westernized world. ISIS is more dangerous than its predecessor because of that. And not because they will be trying massive terror attacks now. But, they are tapped into unlimited funding and influence.
Don't believe me? The King of Jordan, as Westernized as Middle Eastern men come, was willing to trade and deal with ISIS. We were shocked, and appalled. What choice did he have? That enemy is drawing support and finances from Britain, America, France, Germany, Canada. That is a combined net worth of the entire world. Tribal pressure mounted, and he almost caved. He is a smart booger though, and held long enough to let the animals do themselves in. Once the fire video came out, ISIS took care of themselves in Jordan.
The Middle East will never accept democracy. They will never live within Westernized norms. Segments of their population will, and will always be the first victims of the rest of the population. It has been that way for thousands of years. If you have read the Bible, you know the history I just described, as it is the back story of the Old Testament, the Crusades and the last 400 years. It is unchanged and unending.
So, what do we do? We do what we can to help the refugees. We do everything we can to catch, punish and secure the Westerners that come and go there with malice intended. We have to continue to live in a free society that provides the contrast that grates and denigrates the enemy. We never give in, we never negotiate, and we never stop punishing them to the maximum. We have the ability to do that without a ground war.
I would also recommend that we let the current generation of Chris Kyle's go underground over there and find those British accented murdering bastards. They can be willing to stand before their maker for every shot they ever took too. Some of that would take quite a bit of the starch out of their britches, just like it did Al Qaeda and the Taliban. When it starts becoming personally deadly to be that guy on the video, we start getting less videos. Bin Laden disappeared for years because of fear of the Chris Kyle's in our military. My opinion is that it is time for these ISIS jack offs to disappear too.
That is different from sending divisions of our soldiers back to countries that are never going to sustain what we "set up". Look, it never took or got inbedded in Iraq or Afghanistan while we occupied it. It never worked in Egypt or Lybia. It doesn't even work in Jordan or Israel, really. And, that is okay. It does not have to work that way there. Let them figure it out. Leave them be, let them come to their own terms, stay out of reforming their belief systems and culture. We do not need to make them a reflection of us, or like us. We just need to make them understand the very real need to respect the hell out of us.
It has worked with China, the Soviets, the Russians, the French and the Germans for years. None of them really like us, and are not exactly reflections of us and our culture. But, they respect the hell out of us, and that means something. Ronald Reagan taught Qadafi respect with one bombing raid. Taught the French respect in the same bombing raid. We have forgotten how to play the whole chess game in the last 20 years. And that is because we have been led by folks that have zero understanding of what military capability is.
We assume military capability has to be descending on you in mass formation, and occupying your land to reform you. In reality, it is the ability to drop guided munitions in your son's bedroom, your harem's apartments and the French embassy for making us fly an extra 1000 miles. One simple raid that generated 20 years of understanding. No armies, black op prisons, torture tactics. But more effective than the last 20 years of military and foreign diplomacy policy, put together. Our leaders have never served, and don't understand. They don't listen to those that do serve. And, they have not learned as they were on the job.
I believe that Obama is twice the foreign policy president than any we have had since Reagan, the last great foreign policy president. I give credit to George the First as well. A very capable man, and a continuation of the Reagan approach, which he helped craft. The intervening two presidents were both just abyssmal at foreign policy. Asleep at the switch, ignorant of how to operate the switch and surrounded with the least capable, least qualified and most dangerous supporting cast that we have had since the run up to the Civil War.
Lots of folks might disagree with me about that. Some because they can't stand Obamacare, or have gotten their heads full of the Fox News cancer that includes the war on Christmas crowd. Some because they have the MSNBC tumor and can't stand the fact that it requires some muscle flexing to stay safe. Hugging gay whales for Jesus is great, until they drag you under and you drown. The whale does not know or care how much you love and respect it. Neither does Hajii.
But, I maintain that the facts, not the opinions or the political parties, bear me out. There is an approach that will work for ISIS, and it is an approach that only the Americans, with assistance from allies, are able to take. We have to go start killing some targeted folks with a whole lot of ordinance. Drone strikes, SEAL teams, air raids, cruise missiles, those kinds of things. And, call them out by name. If we were to add the name of who is next up on the list when we announce a successful kill, we will shorten the time required to be done. Even if we put the 82nd Airborne on the ground, what I suggest will still be required and the only path to success.
Does that appeal to me as a Christian? No, it sickens me. Does that sound like something that matches up with the romanticized John Wayne informed view of war that most of our current leadership has? No, it is almost totally at odds with that. How we have not learned those lessons in Korea, Vietnam, Iraq, Afghanistan, I do not know, but we are stubbornly and valiantly resistant to them. We just cannot accept that we do not need to send the fleet and the army. How do you get great movies like Saving Private Ryan, if you don't send the army?
I fear we don't have the ability to learn this lesson. I fear that within 12 months we will have people on the ground in Syria, just laying the ground work for the next group like ISIS. They will be brave, valiant, following orders, being heroic, and still driving an outcome that is defeatist and contrary to what our national aims should be. If anyone thinks we got something out of the war in Iraq or Afghanistan that is lasting and providing greater security to our nation today than before 9/11, I would be interested in hearing what that was, and how it is demonstrated.
We need more than shock and horror at tribal behaviors that are centuries old and pervasive through the world. We need a cold, calculating approach that demonstrates what America was, at one time. We were a hornet's nest of cataclysm that did not stop once enraged. Ask the Japanese and Germans how applicable the sleeping giant metaphor was, at one point in time. We need to be that again, but with a different method of application. We need to have 4 planes flying beside each Jordanian plane, and giving ISIS 5 times the fun. We need to see how Assad likes the Qadafi cruise missile treatment. And we need to do it right away, and repetitively until there is a peace that is sustained.
I think Obama understands this. I think Odierno is the least capable and competent Chief of Staff we have had in decades. I don't even know the background of the CNO, or what he looks like. Our military leadership is the weak link, while our civilian leadership needs them the most. We had strong knowledgeable military leadership under George the Dumber, Dubya, whatever. The civilian leadership was so crazy, bad and ill qualified, nothing the uniformed folks would do mattered. I was in uniform then, I was part of that. I felt bad for Powell. His long, illustrious career tied up with Cheney, Rumsfeld and Curious George. It hurt. We lost so many good people for what will be exactly like Vietnam, not one demonstrated change in the outcome of the course of the occupied countries.
Yet, because it has not yet been an American military man/woman on the ISIS videos, we are just kind of voyeurs. It is not quite real. Journalists dumb enough to be there, well, they get what they deserve, no one likes them anyway. They are like carnies in that regard. Aid workers that are dumb enough to be there, well, I mean, really? You are giving them aid?
Let it be a Navy pilot off a carrier in the Gulf, and things will start changing. Let the Paris attack happen in Chicago, and things will be back to 2001. We will come up with the next fabrication to justify the war that replaces the failure during the peace. It was WMD before. Maybe this time it will be Energy Security. We'll come up with something, and go send 200,000 folks. It won't be any more effective.
Why this long post? Just foreshadowing. As a people, we have to learn to operate correctly in the real world. Grant and Sherman showed the entire world how to wage war in the 20th Century. We have shown the world how to be successful in the 21st Century. We just refuse to follow our own blueprint. It will cost us thousands of more lives, and result in no victory.
I love the military, I served, I respect them, I understand them and I support them. They will follow the orders they are given, regardless of what they think of them personally. Well, there are always some Bo Bergdahl's, and that is the subject of another post. But, the vast portion are honorable and dedicated and worth more to me than any other group of people outside America. That is not quite Christian, but it is something I will just have to work on. But, a member of the US Air Force will be more important to me than an Algerian. Sorry, that is just how it is.
It ought to be true and not just words with our leadership as well. I think it is with Obama. It was not with the previous two. Entirely different view points, entirely different failures, but exactly the same issue. I also don't think Obama is scared to dump the Army on someone, but they have to earn the honor of dying at the hands of his army. That is the difference in approach. Iraq had not earned that honor. Neither had Afghanistan. Al Qaeda is not a country, and let's all be honest, Afghanistan is not where we found Bin Laden. We had other agendas, and they were lies from the beginning. That is not a dishonor on the military, but a stain I will never forgive the civilian leadership for, and the rest of us should not either.
That is my point, and the end of this ramble. Don't know exactly what drove it, other than some stupidness I read on the "internets." I welcome the argument, if you want to make it, but it won't change the fact that ends each of my posts.
I love you all.
No comments:
Post a Comment