Sunday, December 28, 2014

Welfare rights

Michigan passed a law that was signed yesterday, to allow drug testing of welfare recipients.  I have very strong opinions on this topic.  I have been randomly drug tested as a condition of employment for the last 30 years.

No one gets irate that our military folks are drug tested and kicked out (not paid), if they fail.  Why should it not be the same for entitlement programs?  It should not be controversial that we test for illegal activity for those receiving government funds.  This should not be the concern.  The concern should be that Senators and Representatives and Governors are not required to be tested, with the same requirements.

In the states where this has already been enacted, the results were not surprising.  There was really no difference in the percentage of welfare recipients doing illegal drugs than the generalized population. Some were, most were not.  That fact alone ought to stop the histrionics that are guaranteed to come over this.  I can already tell you Sharpton will appear somewhere in Michigan over it.  Unless some other poor black kid gets shot, by someone who is not black, somewhere else.  It will have to be a black kid though, Sharpton won't notice a dead Mexican kid, or a black kid shot by someone that is black.  He has proven that over and over and over.

I just wish we would go ahead and have the real debate this is all predicated on.  There is a significant segment of this population that wants rid of "welfare".  It offends them, that there is a handout from the government.  I hear it many times, "if I had my way, we would quit giving handouts, to folks that don't deserve it."

There is the rub.  How do we decide who deserves it?  My uncle is over 70 and has been unable to live on his own due to disability for over 50 years, and has received government assistance that whole time.  Does he deserve the money he receives?  Most people would agree with me, that he does deserve to have his best interests looked after by our society.

As a young married military man, we received food assistance and the government cheese.  Did we deserve the help?  I was working 60 or more hours a week in uniform, with two small children at home.  We qualified and got the assistance.  I hated it, I had too much pride to be able to just accept it, except that is how my kids ate.  So, I put food on our table with that money, and we took it.  Did my family deserve it, because we got paid so poorly by the military?  Was that a reasonable justification?  Or should I have just gotten out of the service and gotten a real paying job?

The guy that got laid off, worked for 15 yesrs at the same company, and can't find a job that pays more than minimum wage, even though he keeps looking.  Does that story qualify for assistance?  Should we have a safety net that makes sure his family eats adequately, and can survive until he finds a job that comes close to replacing his lost income?

No one wants to hand assistance to people that don't "deserve" it.  It infuriates everyone, when we hear the stories of the relative few that embezzle from the government, and get improper payments.  However, my complaining about it is tempered with the knowledge that I do not have the wisdom to set the "fair" boundaries.

It is not fair to my mind to give people assistance because they have kids with no ability to support them.  However, it is not right to have hungry kids that we can prevent.  That has always been the juxtaposition that concerns me about "welfare".  We forget who is really at risk.  It is not about the criminal activity of the few adults that are defrauding us all.

I did not receive aid for dependant children, which is what the program was called, because of me or my condition.  I received that aid because my children were at risk, at my income level, of not having adequate subsistence.  Had it not been for the children, no cheese for us.  My uncle receives aid because he is incapable of earning an income of his own.  Had it not been for his disability, no assistance for him.

We are going to hear a lot about "welfare".  It is a coming debate, as we are slowing coming back to the Reagan era talking points about the poor in this country.  Jeb Bush will pilot the way, saying it in Spanish, to make it more palatable.  It will be all about responsiblity and self accountability.  But, it will never explain how an 8 year is supposed to be self accountable, or impact the family situation the child found itself born into.

But, I suspect that the conversation will sour quickly.  Because unlike the 60's and 70's that led up to Reagan, where income increased bountifully across the board, the 90's and 00's have not been so bountiful.  Proportionally more of the population lives closer to the poverty line today than in the 80's.  The latest recession put a lot of people in a dangerous position.  Lots more people in the nation today are 1 paycheck away from disaster than Reagan ever imagined would occur.

It ought to be interesting.  I want to hear about how all that charity should come from the private community.  We have not heard that much since the late 2000's, as the money dried up everywhere.  I don't know that there will be a creditable candidate that will suggest that.  Probably not even Ron Paul would continue to say it, because it is patently ridiculous.

There is a need, a real, discernible need that must be met.  The only agency with the capacity and system to impact it is our government.  That is the reality.  And perhaps, how God intends for it to be taken care of in America.  Don't laugh, read Jeremiah, God uses secular governments for the good of His people all through the Bible.  Joseph's brothers came to Egypt because of famine, to get "welfare" from the government.

Churches get defrauded all the time, and stolen from and lied to.  Yet, none of the most ardent "welfare" haters suggest the churches stop giving, or test their recipients for drugs.  That would sound as foolish as it looks reading it.  Of course churches get lied to, and get defrauded.  And it is reprehensible.  But, think of all the other good that is being done.  God will judge them.  That is the typical conversation.  I have rarely heard of a church trying to get it's defrauded money back, it doesn't work that way.  Christ doesn't seem to work that way.

There are reforms that need to be made.  I wish we would apply good minds to that task.  Not social workers and the typical HUD experts and lifelong government employees, but real problem solving minds that are not programmed by the entitlement system.  It is not likely to come about, any more than campaign finance reform, Social Security Reform, or overhauling Medicare/Medicaid.  All political third rails, no stomach for anything hard has been apparent since about the last election Theodore Roosevelt ran in, at least in viable candidates.

But, before we get too far in the hysteria of how bad "welfare" is, I ask you to quietly consider my uncle, who literally has had 50 years of life with his family, not in an institution, because of it.  I ask you to consider my young family, that had food for the kids, and was still allowed to continue a military career during the tough period.  If there are justifiable needs, and we are not going to do the things necessary to fix the root cause of those needs, how do we ensure the weak and at risk are cared for?

Is it our responsibility, as healthy, able, contributing citizens, to make sure that we do not have hunger, privation and desperation in this country of such bounty?  Is it our responsibility to give at church as well, to cover the gaps and the holes in the system that exist?  Is it our responsiblity to remember that the folks around us are possibly on assistance, given the last few years economically, before we become vocal about it?

I can tell you that there are many families in that position, that you would never dream could be there.  That is the reality that the Bush and Obama economies have left America.  We are, all of us, responsible for ourselves, with an obligation to care about all of us.  That is the American way, it is in our collective DNA and I can prove it:

We the People of the United States, in Order to form a more perfect Union, establish Justice, insure domestic Tranquility, provide for the common defense, promote the general Welfare, and secure the Blessings of Liberty to ourselves and our Posterity, do ordain and establish this Constitution for the United States of America.

We even use the word "WELFARE".  Kind of neat, how promoting the general welfare was important enough to be in the preamble of our governing documents.  I think we can figure out how to do it, with a little understanding and some ingenuity.

More importantly to the Christians reading this, it is a predicate of our faith, that we are our brother's keeper.  We are to love others better than ourselves.  We are to do for the least of us, in secret, where only our Father sees.  We are to leave vengeance to the Lord.  And we are to cast the last stone, not the first.  That is what I hope our crop of uber-Christian, conservative candidates for the coming election will remember, and what we can teach to our ultra liberal crop of candidates that are circling up.

I love you all

No comments:

Post a Comment